Home / Channel / University beats Apple in patent court, should it be paid?

University beats Apple in patent court, should it be paid?

The smartphone industry is one that is as rife with innovation as it is with patent lawsuits. Apple, Samsung, Qualcomm and many others have dragged one another in and out of court rooms for the past decade or so, attempting to wrestle money and bans on sales from and against their competitors, sometimes legitimately, sometimes seemingly not. The latest combatant in this legal space isn't a hardware maker though, but a university, and it recently beat Apple at its own game.

In the case of Apple vs the University of Wisconsin-Madison, the licensing arm of the university argued that Apple had infringed on a patent owned by the administration for improving the efficiency of its smartphone chips. Despite the financial weight behind Apple's courtroom brawlers too, it won and is now seeking damages for as much as $400 million. While Apple is contesting this, an argument has erupted as to whether this is the sort of litigation that Universities should take part in.

“You need me on that patent wall!” Source: Columbia pictures

The university has argued that it has little choice but to enter into legal battles with some entities, suggesting that in protecting its patents, it is possible to monetise inventions created as research universities like its. Indeed as Reuters points out, many legal experts agree, suggesting that companies have often attempted in recent years to circumvent university patents, leaving them will little alternative.

And it's working too. In 2014-15 alone, the university was able to generate over $100 million through suing those that have illegally used the organisation's technology without license to do so. 2016 may prove to be even more lucrative if the requested compensation comes through.

But there are still detractors. Some highlight the fact that patents are often researched and filed for using public funding, with some of the ownership of the technology resting with the researchers, as well as the university itself. The university has argued however that if educational foundations like it weren't able to legally defend the research patented at the institution, then it would force universities to start private spin-off companies to do so.

Discuss on our Facebook page, HERE.

KitGuru Says: It does seem strange seeing a university splash out on what must have been hefty legal fees, though it feels less problematic since it won. Do you feel like it and others should be able to legally defend inventions made at educational institutions?

Become a Patron!

Check Also

EKWB Whistleblower Dan Henderson speaks to KitGuru

Following on from our recent interview with EKWB's CEO, Leo is now getting the other side of the story, straight from Dan Henderson himself, the one who initially acted as the 'whistleblower' for EKWB's internal issues.


  1. That’d be $400m towards the equipment and staff at that school and the innovations students could be a part of, so why not sue for the money they’re entitled to?

  2. With that 400 million they could buy a handful of college text books and maybe have enough left for a cookie crisp chocloate bar.

  3. Agreed, drop in the ocean for Apple too…

  4. David Anthony White

    At the end of the day, if companies are infringing their copyright they absolutely should sue for damages, they (the company) made money out of something that they (the university) spent time and money developing, and lets not forget that if they don’t sue companies can continue infringing and point at the lack of action taken in the past.

  5. Companies have been profiting from government funded research for decades, while the public that actually funds the research has to pay twice. So yeah, if universities, be they private or public, develop technologies, they should definitely take major corporations to court. That way the money can be invested, and universities don’t have to rely as much on taxes.

  6. i always love to see apple being patent-trolled. and to be fair, im glad this university decided to take them to the court and even more that they won. with $400m they can get some serious upgrades to their equipments, facilities, staff and so on.

  7. $400m could allow them to offer a lot of free scholarships to students in need.

  8. $$$JOBS ON THE NET $$$

    my mate’s stride sister makes $97 hourly on the PC…….…..Last weekend I Bought A Brand new McLaren F1 after earning 18,512$,this was my last month’s paycheck ,and-a little over, $17k last-month . without a doubt it is the most rewarding I have ever had . I started this 10-months ago and pretty much straight away was bringing home at least $97.. per-hour ..Learn More right Here.
    ➤➤➤ http://www.FbFinancialIncomeSupportHomeBasedTrueJobs/Get/$97hourly… ❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦

  9. This is something very interesting that is worth paying your extreme attention ,a very good chance to work for those people who want to use their free time so that they can make some extra money using their computers… I have been working on this for last two and half years and I am earning 60-90 dollar/ hour … In the past week I have earned 13,70 dollars for almost 20 hours sitting ….

    Any special qualification, degree or skills is not necessary for this, just keyboard typing and a good working and reliable internet connection ….

    Not any Time limitations to start work … You may do this work at any time when you willing to do it ….

    Just know how I have been doing this…..….see this (webiste-Iink) on my !profile!` to know how I am working` on this`