Home / Channel / You can’t convict a pirate with an IP address – judge rules

You can’t convict a pirate with an IP address – judge rules

Whether media lobbies and studios were going after individuals, or entire sites full of uploaders and downloaders, the one key piece of evidence that they could use to prove you were the nefarious individual that downloaded that copy of the Hurtlocker, was an IP address. As far as courts were concerned, that was the same as the person downloading the data directly to their brain – you and your IP were one and the same; but no longer. In a landmark case that could spell doom for copyright lobby group usefulness the world over, a judge in Florida has ruled that a person cannot be identified by IP address, as there's no way to prove it was them that used the computer at that time.

Though this provides a loophole for pirates, it certainly does make sense. Indeed there's no way to prove who was using any particular computer at any time without video evidence. It could have been a family member, or a visitor to the house – unlikely, but possible, and the law should protect the innocent as much (if not more) than punishing the guilty.

You'd think with a name like that, it would be more relaxed

This most recent notable case of damage to the idea of IP guilt, comes from a case brought against an individual by porn firm Malibu Media, which has previously been accused of trying to embarrass its customers into settlements, but has now accused an individual of downloading its films via torrent. It cited the IP address of the defendant as evidence and geolocation data that pinpointed the user's house. However, presiding judge Ursula Ungaro disagreed, stating (via TorrentFreak):

“Plaintiff has shown that the geolocation software can provide a location for an infringing IP address; however, Plaintiff has not shown how this geolocation software can establish the identity of the Defendant,” Ungaro said.

“There is nothing that links the IP address location to the identity of the person actually downloading and viewing Plaintiff’s videos, and establishing whether that person lives in this district,” she added.

Ultimately the case was dismissed, as Malibu Media had no leg to stand out without acceptance of the IP ownership.

KitGuru Says: Not all judges may agree with this ruling, but it certainly provides excellent precedent for defendants' legal teams to request for a case to be dismissed if in similar circumstances. 

Become a Patron!

Check Also

Leo Says Ep.73: AMD APUs at CES 2024

KitGuru had a stonkingly successful CES 2024, however there is one small gap in our coverage that needs to be addressed. We gave plenty of coverage to Intel's new Core Ultra range of Meteor Lake laptop processors but appeared to give AMD the cold shoulder, and it is now time to fix that apparent oversight.